Saint Agatha School is accredited by the Ohio Catholic Schools Accrediting Association. As an accredited school, Saint Agatha uses its continuous school improvement plan as a guide for professional development and school growth. Currently, a student learning goal dealing  and a Catholic identity goal are the focus of this work. Periodic progress reviews assist the administration in both fulfilling the requirements of the plan and assessing its effectiveness.

In the fall of 1985, Saint Agatha was named a United States Department of Education Blue Ribbon School. This award recognizes our commitment to academic achievement, community service, instructional best practices, and professional development.

In the fall of 2000, Saint Brigid of Kildare School was named a National Blue Ribbon School for the second time. Saint Agatha has received the award in the high-performing schools category, which includes schools that have achieved among the highest scores in both reading and math as measured by state or national standardized tests in the most recent year tested, regardless of student demographics.

In the fall of 2015, Saint Agatha School was honored to receive our third US Department of Education Blue Ribbon School Award for academic excellence.